Fabre t, piton c, leclouerec g, gervaisdelion f, durandeau a. No 15 pts, mild pain 10 pts, moderate 5 pts, severe or permanent 0. Reliable and valid tools to assess shoulder function are important in research and clinical practice. Oxford shoulder score oss english version for the united kingdom. Is reverse shoulder arthroplasty appropriate for the. Despite the popularity of the constantmurley score cms, a combined patientreport and objective health professional administered shoulder outcome measure, minimal information exists on its reliability or validity. We developed a subjective shoulder rating system ssrs and tested its reliability against a recognized system constantmurley score and a fourpoint verbal rating scale in 200 patients mean age 43 years, range 1871 years. A clinical method of functional assessment of the shoulder. Constant murley score cs, and the american shoulder and elbow surgeons ases questionnaire for the shoulder are also well characterized and accepted in the scienti. The danish version of the modified constantmurley shoulder. The purpose of this study was to examine 1 internal consistency and convergent validity of the cms and 2 the. Apr 19, 2017 translation of the modified constant score testing protocol was done according to established international guidelines.
How comprehensive and efficient are patientreported. Qurious web will have no obligation to provide a refund of any amounts previously paid to rotatemysite. The constant murley shoulder scoring system may be the most commonly used international shoulder scoring scale. Constant murley shoulder outcome score physiopedia it assesses the concept and measurement model of a scale as well as the attributes of reliability, validity and responsiveness to change, among others. The spadi is, together with the patient ases, the shortest selfassessment and shows high validity. Translation of the modified constant score testing protocol was done according to established international guidelines.
B 17 the constant murley score correlates strongly with shoulder specific questionnaires. The total score adds up to be a number out of 100, where a higher score indicates greater shoulder joint. Clinical function improves after subacromial injection of. B 17 the constantmurley score correlates strongly with shoulder specific questionnaires. Pain 15 points a visual analogic scale vas from 0 to 10 points was proposed to estimate the pain of the patient, asking the maximal level of pain felt on a common day. Is a measure of shoulder joint function that assesses pain intensity 15 points, mobility of shoulder joint measured via range of motion 20 points, activities of daily living 40 points, and muscle power 25 points. Shoulder surgery questionnaire before after your operation. The constant score was first published in 1987 reference. The constantmurley 4 score was validated previously, and has high reliability. Disabilities of the arm, shoulder, and hand questionnaire dash and its short version quickdash, shoulder pain and disability index spadi, american shoulder and elbow surgeons ases society standardized shoulder assessment form, constant murley score cs, simple shoulder test sst, oxford shoulder score oss, shoulder disability questionnaire. Goodexcellent constant murley score cms is a 100points scale composed of a number of individual parameters. Home free online constant shoulder score calculator the constantmurley score contains both physiciancompleted and patientreported portions.
The constant murley score cms is widely used to evaluate disabilities associated with shoulder injuries, but it has been criticized for relying on imprecise terminology and a lack of. Pain 15 points a visual analogic scale vas from 0 to 10 points was proposed to estimate the pain of the patient, asking the. Sixtythree patients with shoulder pain caused by degenerative or inflammatory disorders completed the greek version of cs along with the greek versions of sf12 and quick dash scores and the ases rating scale and were included into the validation process. Free online constant shoulder score calculator orthotoolkit. The least efficient scores were the joa andsf36 scores. It was approved and recommended by the executive committee of the european society for surgery of the shoulder and the elbow and has been widely used as an assessment method ever since 2,3,4. Translation, cultural adaptation, validity and reliability of. Six patients in the hemiarthroplasty and 12 patients in the biological resurfacing.
Pain scale and constantmurley subjective questionnaire and objective physical examination. We tried to be as close as possible to the original version proposed by constant and murley, and to the actualized recommendations by constant et al. Constantmurleyscorepatientcompletedportion patientname. The constantmurley shoulder score comprises a physical examination, which is advantageous but restricts the application to the office. If 0 means no pain and 15 is the maximum pain you can experience, please circle where is the level of pain of your should er. This procedure can be directly implemented in all settings as a usual ruler is used for calculating points. Clinical outcomes of hemiarthroplasty and biological. Constantmurley score cms questionnaire is one of the most frequently used shoulderspecific scoring system, which can be specifically used to assess pain and disability in patients with shoulder complaints 7. The subjective shoulder rating system springerlink. As between you and, all modifications or enhancements to the software made by you or members of your household in using this website is true and accurate. Pdf chinese version of the constantmurley questionnaire. Convergent validity of the constantmurley outcome measure in. Shoulder stability was evaluated as described by barrett et al. Constant murley score cms questionnaire is one of the most frequently used shoulderspecific scoring system, which can be specifically used to assess pain and disability in patients with shoulder complaints 7.
The european society for shoulder and elbow surgery esses adopted the scoring system of c constant and a murley 1, 2, 3, 4, 5. Convergent validity of the constantmurley outcome measure. The constantmurley shoulder scoring system may be the most commonly used international shoulder scoring scale. The purpose of this study was to examine 1 internal consistency and convergent validity of the cms and 2 the degree to which other shoulder measures explain. The sst was easy to apply, and compound outcome analysis was possible with the ases shoulder index and dash questionnaire.
Constant scale 56 cs56 went to the printers on friday and should be going out to club members next week. The constant murley shoulder outcome score has become the most commonly used outcome measure for assessing the outcomes of the treatment of shoulder disorders. This is important because, without this, any differences may simply represent inconsistency between two observers rather than a true change. Even in larger condtant of patients makes this method a better comparison of the functional results than the constant murley score reference parameters out of healthy age and gender related control groups. The dash scale was the most complex evaluation instrument. May 10, 2018 the constantmurley score cms was presented in 1987 as an instrument to evaluate overall shoulder function, irrespective of diagnosis. Even in larger condtant of patients makes this method a better comparison of the functional results than the constantmurley score reference parameters out of healthy age and gender related control groups. Statistical analysis statistical analysis was performed with r studio software. For this reason, it must be reliable for it to remain an acceptable measure. Eightyone of the patients evaluated 74% did not have any complaint of pain, while 29 26% presented some degree of residual pain.
Correlation between the ucla and constantmurley scores in. The constant murley score cms is a 100points scale composed of a number of individual parameters. Objectives to assess the reliability, agreement, and validity of the danish version of the modified constantmurley score cms. Translation, cultural adaptation, validity and reliability. What is the abbreviation for constant murley scale. The purpose of our study was to assess the reliability of the new patientbased constantmurley score questionnaire by comparing composite scores and subscores obtained with those obtained using the standard physicianbased constantmurley questionnaire in the same group of patients. Cms questionnaire is recognized as an excellent gauge in assessment of response to treatment in patients with subacromial pain. The constant murley score is a frequently quoted outcome measure used to compare patient groups, techniques and surgeons. Free online constant shoulder score calculator orthotoolkit about the score originally published in 1987 in clinical orthopaedics and related research and revised in 2008 in the journal of shoulder and elbow surgery, the constant murley score was designed to assess the functional state of a normal, a diseased, or a treated shoulder.
Chinese version of the constantmurley questionnaire for. The constant murley 4 score was validated previously, and has high reliability. The baseline characteristics of included studies and the pedro scale are displayed in table 1 and figure 1, respectively. A patientderived constantmurley score is comparable to a. Despite the popularity of the constant murley score cms, a combined patientreport and objective health professional administered shoulder outcome measure, minimal information exists on its reliability or validity. Constant score than those aged 18 to 29 years, 30 to 39 years, 40 to 49 years, and 50 to 59 years p. Aug 16, 2019 constantmurley shoulder outcome score physiopedia it assesses the concept and measurement model of a scale as well as the attributes of reliability, validity and responsiveness to change, among others. These parameters define the level of pain and the ability to carry out the normal daily activities of the patient. Metaanalysis of differences in constantmurley scores for three midshaft clavicular fracture treatments.
Chapter 11 hemiplegic shoulder pain and complex regional pain. Our results suggest that a patientbased questionnaire can be used interchangeably or in place of a clinicianbased questionnaire for subjective and objective items of the constant murley score. Aug 28, 20 we have compared the widely used and wellinvestigated constant murley score and modified it to allow a patientbased score. To evaluate the functional and anatomical results from surgical treatment via arthroscopy in cases of complete rupture of the rotator cuff, using ultrasound images and the constant and murley functional index to investigate the correlation between them. Subjective characteristics are responsible for 35 points. For women, patients aged less than 50 years had a signi. The mean score on constants scale among the patients who had undergone tenodesis of the long head of the biceps was 86. Grading the constant shoulder score difference between normal and abnormal side 30.
The ucla scale presents reliability ranging from moderate to very high. Constantmurley shoulder outcome score physiopedia it assesses the concept and measurement model of a scale as well as the attributes of reliability, validity and responsiveness to change, among others. The constantmurley shoulder outcome score has become the most commonly used outcome measure for assessing the outcomes of the treatment of shoulder disorders. Also the modified constant et al guideline introduced a timeperiod last 24hours to assess pain, but did not introduce a timeperiod for the assess. Metaanalysis of differences in constantmurley scores for. Many commonly utilized pros for rotator cuff tears are lacking in comprehensiveness and efficiency.
741 518 916 1492 1325 1321 64 703 495 1024 1573 1103 237 1313 827 1073 1335 116 900 1561 710 1401 1537 1159 581 984 1443 1258 1170 566 1247 634 190 989 1135 631 1318 475 414 357 459